RudderStack vs Airbyte: Core Differences

With several data integration tools available on the market, choosing the right one can be challenging. This blog aims to comprehensively compare two popular tools: Rudderstack vs Airbyte. 

We will explore their architecture, integration capabilities, and many other attributes to help you determine which tool better fits your business needs.

About Rudderstack

G2 Rating: 4.7/5

RudderStack is an open-source Customer Data Platform(CDP) that provides data pipelines, enabling seamless data collection from any application, website, or SaaS platform for warehousing and use in business tools.

Key Features:

• Data Connectors: 180+ business tools along with custom source and destination.
• Warehouse-first: RudderStack treats your data warehouse as a first-class citizen among destinations, with configurable and near real-time data sync.
• Privacy and Security: You can collect and store customer data without sending everything to a third-party vendor.
• High Availability: Its sophisticated error handling and retry system ensures data availability during downtime. 

About Airbyte

G2 Rating: 4.5/5

Airbyte is an open-source data movement infrastructure for building extract and load (EL) data pipelines. It is designed for versatility, scalability, and ease of use to handle large-scale data integration easily and offers a community-driven approach to building data connectors.

Key Features:

• Data connectors: Airbyte supports 350+ data connectors, with 271 in their Marketplace. 
• Building new connectors: Users can develop their connectors using the language of their choice. 
• The user interface: Airbyte features a UI, PyAirbyte (Python library), API, and Terraform Provider to integrate with your preferred tooling and approach to infrastructure management.
• No Security Compliance Issues: Since Airbyte is a self-hosted solution, it doesn’t risk the user’s infrastructure regarding security or privacy. It depends upon your infrastructure.

RudderStack vs Airbyte: Comparison Metrics

Aspect	Rudderstack	Airbyte
Architecture	Contains two components- the control plane and the data plane.	Contains two components-platform and connectors.
Integration Capabilities	180 popular cloud and warehouse destinations.	350+ prebuilt(271 in marketplace), customizable connectors.(Among which 28 are in Beta Stages)
Data Transformation	Create, test, and publish your JavaScript/Python transformations and libraries directly from your development repository.	Powerful transformations through dbt integration and immediate sync with Airbyte Cloud.
Ease of Use	Intuitive interface, user-friendly, painless setup, detailed documentation, API-first.	A Self-Managed Community (OSS) is an Intuitive Interface, but some engineering understanding is needed to host it.
Setup and Deployment	Simple setup process, active community support.	Easy connector configuration. Deployment requires knowledge of Docker Desktop and Kubernetes.
Pricing	Provides four pricing plans depending on the event volume, including a free plan.	Free core platform (open-source), Airbyte Cloud, with additional features at competitive pricing.
Security and Compliance	Security-first, warehouse native architecture. Provides role-based access control, audit logs, SOC 2 GDPR, and HIPAA compliance	It supports support encryption-in-transit (SSL or HTTPS), SOC 2 Type II, and  ISO 27001 compliance.
Community and Support	Active community support on Slack, detailed documentation, and Live Tech sessions.	Airbyte Cloud customers can access in-app chat support and a Slack and Discourse community. Airbyte open-source users often have to fix the bug themselves or rely on someone from the community to do it.
Use Cases	Ideal for real-time data streaming, widely used in e-commerce, finance, and healthcare.	AI, Analytics, Data Engineering, Marketing, Sales.
Unique Features	Warehouse-first approach, robust security and compliance, developer-focused.	Open-source, extensive connector support, flexible data transformation with dbt integration.

RudderStack vs Airbyte: Head-to-Head Comparison

Architecture and Integration:

• Rudderstack: RudderStack’s architecture consists of 2 major components: the control plane and the data plane.
  • Control Plane: The control plane offers a UI to configure your event data sources and destinations. It includes the front-end application and configuration backend.  
  • Data Plane: The data plane (backend) is RudderStack’s core engine. It consists of three major components: the RudderStack server (rudder-server), the Transformations module, and the Standalone streaming database (PostgreSQL) for event data. 
  • Connectors: Rudderstack offers 180+ popular cloud and warehouse destinations and includes 15+ SDK sources to make simple event data collection from websites and mobile apps.

• Airbyte: Airbyte’s architecture comprises the platform and the connectors.
  • Platform: It provides all the horizontal services required to configure and run data movement operations, such as the UI, configuration API, job scheduling, alerting, etc.
  • Connectors: They are independent modules that push/pull data to/from sources and destinations. They are packaged as Docker images, which allows total flexibility over the technologies used to implement them.

Data Transformation and Processing:

• Rudderstack
  • Transformations API helps to manage your RudderStack Transformations and Libraries.
  •  Allows you to use transformations across your Event Streams, Cloud Extract, and Reverse ETL pipelines in both cloud and device modes.
  • Users can create, test, and publish their JavaScript/Python transformations and libraries directly from their development repository.
    
• Airbyte
  • More focused on post-load Transformations.
  • Using the dbt Cloud integration, you can create and run dbt transformations immediately following syncs in Airbyte Cloud. 
  • This allows you to transform raw data into a suitable format for analysis and reporting, including cleaning and enriching the data. However, this requires a paid version of dbt Cloud. 

Ease of Use and Setup

• Rudderstack: RudderStack offers:
  • A user-friendly interface with intuitive setup processes. 
  • Detailed documentation and active community support are available on Slack.  
  • The platform’s API-first design ensures smooth integration with existing systems.
• Airbyte: Airbyte offers:
  • An open-source model, providing its core platform for free. 
  • Comprehensive documentation and tutorials. 
  • Airbyte Cloud customers can access in-app chat support and a Slack and Discourse community.

Pricing and Cost Considerations

• Rudderstack: Provides 4 pricing models based on event volume.
  • Free: $0 for 1 million monthly events.
  • Starter: Starting with $500 for 3 million monthly events to $1,425 for 25 million monthly events. 
  • Growth: Custom Pricing
  • Enterprise: Custom Pricing
• Airbyte: It offers 4 pricing models.
  • Open Source: This is self-hosted and free.
  • Cloud: This is hosted on Airbyte Cloud and has a free trial. 
  • Team: This is cloud-hosted, and you can contact the sales team for pricing.
  • Enterprise: This is self-hosted, and you can contact the sales team for pricing.

If you are looking for a cloud-hosted open-source tool, Airbyte is your go-to solution, but if you need to ingest a large event volume, you should choose Rudderstack. 

Security and Compliance

• Rudderstack: Rudderstack offers:
  • Security-first, warehouse native architecture gives you complete ownership, control, and transparency.
  • Enterprise-ready security features such:
    • SSO for tools like Okta and OneLogin.
    • SSH Tunnel.
    • Permission Management to mas PHI and PII information.
    • Audit logs
  • Industry-standard compliance includes SOC 2 Type 2, HIPAA, and GDPR.
• Airbyte: Airbyte offers:
  • In version 0.44.0, Airbyte Open Source runs a security self-check during setup to help users secure their Airbyte instance.
  • Airbyte Cloud and Airbyte Enterprise provide role-based access control.
  • Airbyte Open Source connectors support encryption-in-transit (SSL or HTTPS).
  • It provides compliances such as:
    • SOC 2 Type II
    • ISO 27001 
    • Third-party assessments and penetration tests.

Use Cases and Case Studies

Rudderstack

• It is ideal for real-time data migration and is used in various industries, such as retail, e-commerce, finance, and healthcare. 
• Companies like ‘Khatabook’ are using Rudderstack to allow cost-effective scaling to over 6 billion monthly events. 

Airbyte

• Airbyte’s flexibility and extensive connector support make it suitable for various use cases, such as sales, marketing, data engineering, etc. 
• Companies like ‘datadog’ use Airbyte’s platform to power their self-serve analytics tool. Airbyte’s ease of use and extensibility allowed any team in the company to push their data into the platform – without assistance from the data team! 

Pros and Cons

• Rudderstack Pros
  • Warehouse-first approach
  • Real-time and batch processing
  • Strong data transformation capabilities
  • Robust security and compliance features
  • Fully pay-as-you-use with no cap on events per MTU. 
• Rudderstack Cons
  • Steep learning curve
  • Pricing can be event volume-dependent
  • A limited number of data sources for ETL. 
• Airbyte Pros
  • Provides PyAirbyte, Airbyte’s open-source Python library, to fulfill advanced data integration needs.
  • Integrates with 350+ popular sources and destinations.
  • Custom-built connectors run in Docker containers so that you can write them in any coding language.
  • Flexible data transformation with dbt integration
  • Competitive pricing, including free core platform
• Airbyte Cons
  • Per-credit pricing is confusing.
  • Frequent updates may force users to install new versions often.
  • Steep learning curve and require technical knowledge. 

Why is Hevo Data leading the ELT Race?

While looking for an ETL tool that fits your business needs, Rudderstack and Airbyte have pros and cons. Rudderstack is a simple and user-friendly tool that provides enterprise-level security due to its warehouse-first approach. Airbyte, on the other hand, is an open-source tool that is highly flexible and customizable, but it can be complex and have a steep learning curve. 

Meet Hevo, an automated data pipeline platform that provides the best of both tools. Hevo offers:

1. A user-friendly interface.
2. Robust data integration and seamless automation. 
3. It supports 150+ connectors, providing all popular sources and destinations for your data migrations.
4. The drag-and-drop feature and custom Python code transformation allow users to make their data more usable for analysis. 
5. A transparent, tier-based pricing structure.
6. Excellent 24/7 customer support. 

These features combine to place Hevo at the forefront of the ELT market.

Conclusion

Choosing the right ETL tool is crucial to meet your data management needs and seamless data migration. Depending on your needs, you can choose between Rudderstack and Airbyte, for example:

• You can opt for Airbyte’s open-source free plan for a budget-friendly solution.
• If you need enterprise-level security and compliance, you should go for Rudderstack.

While both Airbyte and Rudderstack are potential solutions, they lack on some fronts. On the other hand, Hevo is a simple, user-friendly solution that migrates your data in real time. 

Try Hevo’s 14-day free trial and experience seamless data migration. 

Frequently Asked Questions